I was on NPR's News & Notes on Monday, discussing for the umpteenth time the economic malaise: the highest number of jobs lost in a single year since 1945, little hope in sight for those still looking for jobs, and a deal by one of the country's largest banks to allow judges to modify home mortgages rather than see the homes fall into foreclosure.
For the most part I could have recited the same conversation from months ago: things went from bad to worse and there isn't much hope in sight for a quick turnaround. But the Citibank mortgage deal, and some other data about what happens to many homeowners who have gotten help with their mortgages in the past year, were striking and interesting. Here's why:
Citibank and most other banks had resisted judges having the authority to modify mortgages for the obvious reason: if a homeowner falls behind on payments and the bank forecloses, at least the bank has a chance to take the house back and resell it -- possibly (though not likely) recovering at least all the principal it lent. But if a judge can modify the terms of the loan, the bank might stand to lose some of what it put up without ever getting the chance to see what the house might fetch on the open market and it almost certainly loses some or all of the interest revenue it expected from that loan.
You can see why a bank would be loathe to leave the fate of its mortgage business in the hands of any court. By agreeing, it could be argued that Citi and probably many other banks to follow, are accepting the grim reality that they don't have a chance to break even on many of their mortgage loans anyway (big surprise there) and are resigned to leave it in the hands of judges who might not have viewed their lending practices with particular reverence.
But here's where it gets tricky: there's new evidence that whatever workarounds judges come up with might not help troubled homeowners anyway. Comptroller of the Currency John C. Dugan said last week that more than half the mortgages that had been modified in the first half of 2008 were delinquent again within six months.
Think about that: If you were in trouble on your mortgage in January and got help, it's more likely than not that by July you were behind again. Not a good sign for Citibank, the judges about to perform legal surgery on its mortgages or the homeowners looking for a helping hand.
There could be any number of reasons for this but I'll give you my favorite one: too many people just bought too much house, and too many banks approved those people for loans bigger than they ever should have gotten. If you only make $40 grand a year, no amount of loan modification will help you keep a $300,000 home.
The bad news continues...
I'm Keith Reed, a business reporter, national economics commentator and blogger and this site is part of my personal mission to help more people -- particularly young people -- better understand the economy and manage their own finances
Showing posts with label Citibank. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Citibank. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 13, 2009
Wednesday, December 3, 2008
Getting out of Citibank's credit card rate hike
In my Nov. 21 post I wrote about a coming across the board rate hike for Citibank credit card holders. Yesterday a blog reader got her note in the mail about the changes:
I'll do another post explaining what LIBOR is and why it matters a lot to your credit cards and other loans later. But the bottom line is that Citibank is jacking up the rates on its credit cards. In this reader's case, way up:
Here's the fine print about opting out: if you do so, you'll be able to use your card and pay the same interest rate you have now but only until your card's expiration date. After that, Citibank's giving you the boot. They'll close your account as of your expiration date, so if that's your only card, you'll need to start looking for a new one.
Once the card is closed, you'll still get billed for any remaining balance, which will accrue interest at the same rate you had while the card was open until you pay it off.
One complication could be how this affects your credit score. By closing a credit card account, it's possible to damage yours score. I'm not sure how that will work in this case. Technically, Citibank is severing the relationship but the argument could (and likely will) be made that by opting out, you're in-effect choosing to close the account yourself.
One solution might be to do nothing. If you're not carrying a balance on an open Citibank-issued card, the rate hike won't matter as long as you don't charge anything that takes longer than one billing cycle to pay off. That way you don't have to worry about a credit score hit for closing the account. In the meantime, shop around for a new card with a lower rate that you can put your purchases on.
Hope that helps.
I. We are changing how we calculate your variable APR for purchases:
We are increasing your variable APR for purchases. Your purchase APR will equal the LIBOR Rate plus 16.99%, with a minimum of APR of 19.99%.
As of September 17, 2008, this purchase APR is 19.99%. The APR equals a daily periodic rate of 0.0548%
II. We are changing how we calculate your variable APR for cash advances:
We are increasing your variable APR for cash advances. Your cash advance APR will equal the LIBOR Rate plus 19.99%, with a minimum of APR of 21.99%.
As of September 17, 2008, this cash advance APR is 22.73%. The APR equals a daily periodic rate of 0.0623%.
I'll do another post explaining what LIBOR is and why it matters a lot to your credit cards and other loans later. But the bottom line is that Citibank is jacking up the rates on its credit cards. In this reader's case, way up:
My purchase apr is going to skyrocket from 8.99% to 19.99%Still, she wants to know if she can get out of the deal. The answer is yes. According to the notice, Citibank is giving cardholders the chance to "opt out" of the rate hike by calling or writing the company by Jan. 31, 2009. If you don't do it before then, prepare for sticker shock on your bills.
Luckily I only use this card for balance transfers and the rate I got when I did the balance transfers were 1.99% until the balance is paid off.
Here's the fine print about opting out: if you do so, you'll be able to use your card and pay the same interest rate you have now but only until your card's expiration date. After that, Citibank's giving you the boot. They'll close your account as of your expiration date, so if that's your only card, you'll need to start looking for a new one.
Once the card is closed, you'll still get billed for any remaining balance, which will accrue interest at the same rate you had while the card was open until you pay it off.
One complication could be how this affects your credit score. By closing a credit card account, it's possible to damage yours score. I'm not sure how that will work in this case. Technically, Citibank is severing the relationship but the argument could (and likely will) be made that by opting out, you're in-effect choosing to close the account yourself.
One solution might be to do nothing. If you're not carrying a balance on an open Citibank-issued card, the rate hike won't matter as long as you don't charge anything that takes longer than one billing cycle to pay off. That way you don't have to worry about a credit score hit for closing the account. In the meantime, shop around for a new card with a lower rate that you can put your purchases on.
Hope that helps.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)